Reflection: Testing the Spirits: Listening for God’s Voice in a Noisy World

Brief Background:
Saint John Neumann (1811–1860) was a Bohemian-born Catholic priest who became the fourth Bishop of Philadelphia and one of the most influential Catholic leaders in 19th-century America. A member of the Redemptorists, he was deeply committed to pastoral care, especially for immigrants, the poor, and working families.
As bishop, he organized one of the first diocesan Catholic school systems in the United States, expanding parish schools so children could receive both a solid education and formation in the faith. Known for his humility, tireless work ethic, and accessibility, he often traveled on foot to serve his people. He was canonized in 1977 and became the first male American saint.
St. John is the patron saint of Catholic education and Catholic schools, students and teachers, immigrants, catechists and parish educators
His life is a powerful reminder that evangelization happens through education, presence, and faithful service, especially among those on the margins.
REFLECTION:
We live in a world filled with many voices. Everyone has an opinion, a platform, a “truth” they want us to accept. Some of these voices sound convincing, even spiritual. They may speak about peace, success, freedom, or self-fulfillment. But Saint John, writing to an early Christian community facing confusion, gives a sober warning: “Do not trust every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they belong to God.”
The Spirit of God always leads us toward Jesus Christ—not a Jesus remade in our own image, but Jesus who truly came in the flesh, who suffered, loved, forgave, and gave Himself completely. The Spirit of God draws us into communion: deeper love for God, greater charity toward others, and a willingness to live according to the Gospel even when it is uncomfortable. Where the Spirit of God is present, there is humility, truth, and a quiet strength that builds up the Body of Christ.
The spirit of the world, on the other hand, often sounds attractive. It promises quick answers and easy comfort. It tells us to avoid sacrifice, to follow only what feels good, and to reshape truth around personal preference. The spirit of the world separates belief from action—faith without love, spirituality without responsibility. It resists the Cross and prefers a Christ without demands.
Saint John reminds us that discernment is not about being suspicious or fearful; it is about belonging. “You belong to God,” he says. That belonging gives us confidence. The Spirit of God does not shout over the noise of the world; He speaks through faithfulness, through the teachings handed on by the Church, through love lived in daily, ordinary ways.
A simple test can guide us:
- Does this spirit lead me closer to Christ as He truly is?
- Does it move me to love others more deeply and concretely?
- Does it draw me into unity with the Church rather than isolation?
If the answer is yes, then we are listening to the Spirit of God. If not, Saint John urges us to pause, pray, and discern again.
In a noisy world, this passage invites us to slow down, to listen carefully, and to remember that the Spirit who lives in us is greater than the spirit of the world. When we remain in Christ—through prayer, love, and fidelity—we learn, little by little, to recognize His voice and to walk confidently in His light.
