Reflection: You Can't Please Everyone

Fr. Eseese 'Ace' Tui • September 16, 2026

Brief Background:

St. Cornelius:  Pope during a time of persecution and division in the Church. He defended the reconciliation of Christians who repented after abandoning the faith. Patron against epilepsy and seizures.


St. Cyprian:  Bishop of Carthage, theologian, and friend of Cornelius who strongly defended the unity of the Church. Patron of North Africa.


Both were martyrs of the third century and are celebrated together for their witness to faith, mercy, and Church unity.


REFLECTION:


One of the things they taught us firsthand in the seminary was this: “You can’t please everyone.” And I remember thinking, “Well, I already learned that lesson before seminary!” Before this life, when I was working as a manager, I learned very quickly that no matter what decision you make, somebody is going to be unhappy. You make the schedule one way, someone complains. You change it, somebody else complains. You enforce a rule, you’re too strict. You give someone a little flexibility, now you’re too lenient. And sometimes you just want to ask, “Okay, what do you people want from me?”


Jesus could probably say the same thing in today’s Gospel.


He says John the Baptist came neither eating bread nor drinking wine, and people said, “He is possessed by a demon.” Then Jesus comes eating and drinking, and they say, “Look, he is a glutton and a drunkard.” John was too strict. Jesus was too welcoming. No matter what God did, somebody found something wrong with it.


Saints Cornelius and Cyprian, whom we celebrate today, knew something about that.


They lived during a difficult period of persecution in the early Church. Many Christians, afraid of imprisonment or death, denied their faith. When the persecution eased, some of them wanted to return to the Church. That created a major controversy. Some basically said, “They betrayed Christ. They should never be allowed back.” Others wanted to welcome them back without taking seriously what had happened.


Cornelius and Cyprian tried to walk the more difficult road: take sin seriously, but never give up on the sinner. Those who had fallen could repent, do penance, and be reconciled to the Church. And guess what? They couldn’t please everyone either.


That is why our first reading is so fitting. Saint Paul tells us, “Love is patient, love is kind… it bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.”

We usually hear those words at weddings, but Paul originally wrote them to a Church that was divided. People were arguing, competing, and thinking they were better than one another. Paul reminds them that you can have knowledge, gifts, accomplishments, even tremendous faith—but if you do not have love, you have missed the point.


Cornelius and Cyprian show us that Christian love does not mean making everybody happy. Sometimes love requires us to tell the truth. Sometimes love requires correction. Sometimes love requires forgiveness. And sometimes love means giving someone another chance when everybody else has already written that person off.


Jesus ends today’s Gospel by saying, “Wisdom is vindicated by all her children.” Eventually, the fruits reveal whether something truly comes from God.


Maybe that is something all of us need to remember. Whether we are priests, parents, teachers, administrators, managers, or simply trying to live our faith, we are never going to please everyone. So perhaps the better question is not, “Is everyone happy with me?” The better question is, “Am I loving them?”


Am I patient? Am I kind? Am I willing to speak the truth? Am I willing to forgive? Am I still hoping for the good of the other person, even when we disagree?

Because opinions change. Popularity fades. Arguments eventually pass.


But as Saint Paul reminds us: “Faith, hope, love remain, these three; but the greatest of these is love.”